Understanding and Comparing Information from Two Texts
Understanding and Comparing Information from Two Texts Objective: Students will learn how to compare and contrast information presented in two different texts on the same topic, identifying similarities and differences in key details.
Learning Objectives
- Identify key details in two different texts about the same topic.
- Explain how the information in the two texts is similar and how it is different.
- Use a Venn diagram to organize similarities and differences.
- Discuss why authors may present information differently.
Materials Needed
- Two short nonfiction texts on a similar topic (e.g., two articles about animals, weather, or historical events)
- Paper and pencils
- Venn diagram worksheet for comparing texts
- Highlighters or colored pencils
Key Vocabulary
- Compare
- To look at two or more things and find ways they are alike.
- Contrast
- To look at two or more things and find ways they are different.
- Key details
- Important pieces of information that help explain or tell more about the main idea.
Detailed Activities
Reading and Comparing Two Texts
- 1. Introduce the topic and explain that students will read two short texts about the same subject.
- 2. Read the first text aloud with the student, pausing to discuss key details and main ideas.
- 3. Read the second text aloud, again discussing important information and main ideas.
- 4. Provide a Venn diagram worksheet and help the student list details that are found in both texts in the overlapping section.
- 5. Help the student write details unique to each text in the separate sections of the diagram.
- 6. Review the completed Venn diagram together and discuss how the texts are similar and different.
- 7. Ask the student to explain why two authors might present information differently about the same topic.
Parent & Instructor Notes
- This lesson helps your child practice comparing and contrasting information, a key reading skill that builds comprehension.
- You can support your child by reading the texts together and asking questions about what they learned.
- Encourage your child to express their thoughts in their own words and use the Venn diagram to organize ideas visually.
Assessment Questions
- What is one detail that both texts share about the topic?
- Can you name a difference between the two texts?
- Why do you think the authors wrote about the topic in different ways?
- How did the Venn diagram help you understand the information?
Extension Ideas
- Have your child find two short articles or pictures at home about the same subject and create their own comparison chart.
- Encourage your child to write a short paragraph explaining the similarities and differences between two things they are interested in.
- Play a comparison game where you give two items or ideas and your child tells how they are alike and different.
Frequently Asked Questions
Start by focusing on just one or two details and use guiding questions like ‘What is this text mostly about?’ and ‘What new information does the other text add?’ This helps narrow the focus.
You can read the texts together aloud or have your child read quietly. Take as much time as needed but try to keep the total lesson around 45 minutes for focus.
Teacher’s Guide
Common Misconceptions:
- Students might focus only on surface details rather than key information when comparing texts.
- They may think that texts must be exactly the same to be similar, missing subtle differences or shared themes.
Scaffolding Ideas:
For Struggling Students:
- Use shorter texts with clear and simple language.
- Provide sentence starters for writing comparisons, such as ‘Both texts say…’, ‘One text says…’, ‘The difference is…’.
- Work together on filling out the Venn diagram before independent work.
For Advanced Students:
- Challenge students to find more subtle differences like author’s purpose or point of view.
- Ask students to create their own pair of texts on a topic and write a comparison paragraph.
- Include texts with more complex vocabulary or multiple perspectives.
Pacing Recommendations:
- Spend about 10-15 minutes reading and discussing the first text.
- Spend another 10-15 minutes on the second text.
- Use 15-20 minutes to complete the Venn diagram and discuss the comparison.
Standards
- 8.RI.9 — Compare and contrast the information gained from two texts on the same topic in order to demonstrate understanding of the subject.
Printable Worksheet
Plan Your Own Lesson
Looking for a custom lesson plan? Try our Lesson Planning Generator — create standards-based plans for any topic, instantly!
Common Core Aligned Lesson Plans
Looking for another common core lesson? See all of the lesson plans here.
More Free Lesson Plans
We’re adding more every week! Check back soon or explore all our lesson plans here.
Leave a Reply