Comparing and Contrasting Two Stories
Comparing and Contrasting Two Stories Objective: Students will be able to compare and contrast two different stories by identifying similarities and differences in characters, settings, and major events.
Learning Objectives
- Identify key elements (characters, settings, events) in two stories.
- Describe similarities between the two stories.
- Describe differences between the two stories.
- Use a Venn diagram to organize thoughts about the stories.
Materials Needed
- Two age-appropriate storybooks or printed short stories
- Venn diagram worksheet
- Pencils and crayons
Key Vocabulary
- Compare
- To look at two or more things and find out how they are alike.
- Contrast
- To look at two or more things and find out how they are different.
- Character
- A person, animal, or figure in a story.
Detailed Activities
Read and Discuss Two Stories
- Read the first story aloud to the student, pausing to discuss main characters, setting, and important events.
- Read the second story aloud, again discussing the same elements.
- Ask the student to recall details about each story to reinforce understanding.
Use a Venn Diagram to Compare and Contrast
- Introduce the Venn diagram and explain how the overlapping part shows similarities, and the non-overlapping parts show differences.
- Help the student list characters, settings, and events unique to each story in the separate circles.
- List similarities in the overlapping section.
- Encourage the student to use crayons to color the diagram to make it engaging.
Discuss Findings
- Talk about what the student noticed about the two stories.
- Ask questions such as: Which characters were similar? How were the settings different? What events happened in one story but not the other?
- Praise the student for their observations and encourage them to share their favorite story.
Parent & Instructor Notes
- This lesson is designed to be interactive and fun while helping your child develop critical thinking skills about stories.
- Take your time reading and discussing; it’s okay to read the stories more than once if needed.
- Use simple language when explaining compare and contrast, and encourage your child to express their thoughts freely.
Assessment Questions
- Can you tell me one way the two stories are alike?
- Can you tell me one way the two stories are different?
- Who was your favorite character in each story and why?
Extension Ideas
- Have your child draw pictures of their favorite characters from each story and explain the differences.
- Create a short story together that combines elements from both stories.
- Use other pairs of books to practice comparing and contrasting with different themes or characters.
Frequently Asked Questions
Encourage them by prompting with simple questions like ‘Did both stories have animals?’ or ‘Were the stories set in different places?’ Also, reading the stories more than once can help.
No, but it can be easier for children to compare stories if they share some common elements like characters or settings.
Teacher’s Guide
Common Misconceptions:
- Children may confuse compare and contrast and list only differences or only similarities.
- They might focus too much on details rather than main story elements like characters or events.
Scaffolding Ideas:
For Struggling Students:
- Use picture books with clear and simple storylines to make it easier to identify key elements.
- Provide a partially completed Venn diagram to guide their thinking.
For Advanced Students:
- Encourage them to write sentences explaining the similarities and differences.
- Ask them to compare the authors’ styles or the lessons/morals in each story.
Pacing Recommendations:
- Allow more time for discussion if the child is new to comparing stories.
- If the child is comfortable, shorten story reading time and spend more on analysis and discussion.
Standards
- 2.RL.9 — Compare and contrast two or more versions of the same story by different authors or from different cultures.
Printable Worksheet
Plan Your Own Lesson
Looking for a custom lesson plan? Try our Lesson Planning Generator — create standards-based plans for any topic, instantly!
Common Core Aligned Lesson Plans
Looking for another common core lesson? See all of the lesson plans here.
More Free Lesson Plans
We’re adding more every week! Check back soon or explore all our lesson plans here.
Leave a Reply